When the next tier is the wrong move
A pricing page likes round allowances: 10,000, then 50,000. The bill you actually pay is often the smaller plan plus the extra-email rate, until that rate crosses the next plan's price. The crossover is the only number that matters.
Postmark's $42 example is a bill, not the minimum
Postmark's monthly pricing article walks through the Basic 10,000 plan. The plan is $15. Fifteen thousand emails past that allowance, at $1.80 per 1,000, are $27. The article's total is $42. Sending continues. You do not have to upgrade for the mail to go out.
That example holds if you stay on Basic. It is not the cheapest path in the same published table. Platform's 10,000 plan is $18 with extras at $1.20 per 1,000. The same 15,000 extra emails cost $18, so 25,000 emails come to $36. Pro's 10,000 plan is $16.50 with extras at $1.30 per 1,000, which is also $36. The guide shows Platform and names the tie, because the two totals match and Platform is the plan with the broader published feature list.
Basic's own next step, 50,000 emails for $55, is the right buy only once the overage on the smaller plan passes $55. On Basic that happens before you reach 50,000: 40,000 extra emails at $1.80 per 1,000 are $72, and $15 + $72 is $87. At exactly 50,000 the guide therefore selects Basic 50,000 at $55, not the 10,000 plan plus a full step of overage.
One email over 10,000 does not justify that jump. At the published prorata it adds $0.0018 on Basic, and the total is $15.0018. Rounding that to $15.00 would hide the overage, so the guide keeps the extra digits. Postmark's article does not say whether a partial thousand is rounded up by their billing system. The figure follows the worked example, which divides evenly.
Far above the allowance, the overage rate can beat the base price
Near the top of Postmark's published range the order flips again. Basic 1,500,000 is $775 with extras at $1.70 per 1,000. Pro 1,500,000 is $852.50 with extras at $1.20 per 1,000. At 2,999,999 emails the Pro overage is cheaper than Basic's, so the guide selects Pro. At 3,000,000 the pricing page stops showing a price and asks you to contact sales. That volume is Quote, not an extension of the $1.20 rate.
SMTP2GO publishes both the jump and the extra-email rate
On SMTP2GO's pricing page, the plan list the page script reads prices 5,000 emails at $5 with extras at $0.001 each, and 10,000 emails at $15 with extras at $0.0012 each. Five thousand extras on the smaller plan are $5, so 10,000 emails come to $10, which is less than buying the 10,000 plan.
The guide shows that $10 and marks it Estimate. The rate is published. A cap is not. The 10,000 plan at $15 is printed beside it as the price that does not depend on extras. That $15 row can win the cheapest badge. The $10 row cannot.
The placeholder cards in the HTML, before that script runs, show amounts such as $10 on a different tier. Those placeholders are ignored. Yearly billing, which is ten months' price on the tiers checked, is also ignored in the monthly rank. It is a prepay, not a lower monthly rate.
What to do with a tier table
Write down three numbers before you upgrade: the price of the plan you are on, the extra-email rate, and the price of the next plan that covers the volume. Divide the price gap by the rate. That many extra emails is the crossover. If the provider does not publish the rate, or says the overage is capped without saying the cap, do not treat the crossover as a fact. Mailtrap and Resend are in that second group, and the allowance guide keeps them there.